SEBI registered Investment advisor (RIA) with Registration number – INA 000000342.
How to select good Mutual Funds for long term wealth creation?

Last week, I was in a coaching centre with my 15 year old daughter for her admission into the engineering entrance coaching. The course which will run for the next 2 years along with her +1 and +2 studies cost me a cool 2.6 Lakhs. While coming back after her admission, I have done a back calculation and was surprised by the findings. I was interested in knowing, the amount, I should have saved monthly by way of SIPs for accumulation of this 2.6lakhs.  I was surprised to see that a monthly SIP of Rs.200/- in Franklin India Bluchip Fund for the last 15 years would have created this amount!

My business partner was interested in hearing this data because he is having a new born son and is interested in knowing, how much he should save for his son.

Let us assume an inflation of 8% in educational expenses. The present cost of 2.6 Lakhs will become 8 lakhs after 15 years. Assuming a return of 15% from diversified equity fund for the next 15 years, he has to invest 1200/- per month for the next 15 years.

This is the power of compounding. If you start early, you can achieve your financial goals by saving small amounts.

In the last article, we have discussed the concept of mutual funds. In this article, we will discuss, how, to select good mutual funds for long term wealth creation.

As we discussed in the previous article, the fund manager pools the amount received from various investors and invest in shares of select companies/debt schemes as per the mandate of the scheme. In this case of professional fund management, why there is huge difference between the performances of different schemes? From these large number of mutual fund schemes in the market, how we can identify the winner for long term investment?

There are some ratios you must know, if you want to analyse a mutual fund.

Sharpe Ratio: Generally we judge mutual funds performance by the returns only. But the better parameter is return with respect to the risk taken. The Sharpe Ratio of a fund measures whether the returns that a fund delivered were commensurate with the kind of volatility it exhibited. This ratio looks at both, returns and risk, and delivers a single measure that is proportional to the risk adjusted returns.

Sharpe ratio is nothing but risk adjusted returns. So a mutual fund with higher Sharpe Ratio is better.

Alpha: This is very important ratio in mutual funds. Alpha is a measure of an investment’s performance on a risk-adjusted basis. It takes the volatility (price risk) of a fund portfolio and compares its risk-adjusted performance to a benchmark index. The excess return of the investment relative to the return of the benchmark index is its alpha.

Simply stated, alpha is often considered to represent the value that a fund manager adds to the fund return. A positive alpha of 1 means the fund has outperformed its benchmark index by 1%. Correspondingly, a similar negative alpha would indicate an underperformance of 1%. For investors, the more positive the alpha is, the better it is.

Comparison of Alpha & Sharpe Ratio of 10 select funds

Sl. No Fund Name Sharpe Ratio Alpha CAGR for the last 5 Years(As on 4th April.2011)
1 Sundaram Select Midcap Fund 0.38 6.43 13.80%
2 DSP black Rock top100 equity 0.42 4.8 15.81%
3 ICICI Prudential Dynamic 0.48 6.88 15.02%
4 Birla Sunlife Frontline Equity 0.41 5.47 17.06%
5 Reliance Growth 0.35 3.81 14.71%
6 JM Basic -0.21 -24.08 -4.60%
7 L&T Contra 0.07 -6.33 -0.10%
8 JM Emerging Leaders Fund -0.13 -18.92 -9.70%
9 Taurus Discovery Fund -0.18 -18.13 -1.80%
10 L&T Global Advantage Fund -0.21 -14.25 -7.10%

You can see from the above list that the first 5 funds which have delivered good returns in the last 5 years have higher Sharpe Ratio and higher Alpha compared to the next 5 funds, which were bad performers in the same period.

If you cannot, analyse these ratios, the following points can be evaluated while selecting mutual funds.

1.  Invest in funds with atleast 5 year track record. Avoid new fund offering (NFO) unless, it is coming out with a new theme. The Rs.10/- NAV concept is a marketing technique and it will not help you in getting better returns.

2.   Long term performance of the fund: It should figure out in top 10-15 at least over 5 yrs returns criteria.

3.  They should have a track record of consistently outperforming its Bench mark (this shows that they did better than what they were tracking).

4.   Study the quality of the management. Don’t just buy MF just because it returns 40% last year, but you have never heard of its parent name.

5.   Once you shortlist some mutual funds , then look for its portfolio allocation see how it has put its money for large , Medium and small cap companies . If its concentration is high on mid and small cap funds, it means that it has more than average risk, but potential for very great returns also, choose it if it fits your risk appetite.

Most mutual funds on an average invest in around 50-60 companies. If you buy 3-4 diversified equity mutual funds, you are going to invest in close to 100 companies overall (considering there will be some overlaps). Now when you buy another diversified equity mutual fund, most probably, the money is going to be invested in almost same set of companies.  So what you have to understand is that after a certain point adding more mutual funds of the same category is of no much value for the portfolio.

Ideally, you can have a core portfolio of 2- 3 large cap funds, one mid cap fund and one thematic fund, one index fund and one gold ETF. Also review the performance of these funds annually and take corrective action if required.

Also ensure that, you maintain the overall asset allocation between different asset classes like equity, debt, real estate and gold as per your risk profile.

In the next article, we will recommend you some good funds for wealth creation based on the above criteria.

10 Comments

  • V. Prasanna Venkatesan Posted June 11, 2011 6:41 am

    A very good article that simply explained Sharpe Ratio and Alpha. I was explained about this by a training manager (?) before but was very much confusing.

    MFs are managed by a team of fund managers. They work based on the instructions of the directors or controlling officials. The policy of the fund in terms of Risking depend on the managing authorities or directors. Will that change if the policy of the instructor change or it is fixed for each fund?

    In MF, the NAV depends on the total asset vs number of units given. As this MFs are not having lockin periods, (but for ELS) there is a chance of reduction of Unit Value if a mass is withdrawing after seeing the profit. Now, they can avoid taxing if they withdraw after one year. In that case, will the continuing clients will be affected or not. (Or) to bring back the NAV value, will the MF team take risk or not?
    Please clarify sir.

    • Finvin Posted June 13, 2011 1:00 pm

      Thanks Prasanna.
      Normally, all funds are having their Investment objective laid down clearly in the offer document.The Fund Manager has to adhere to that.Later if the AMC want to change the mandate, it has to get the approval from the Trustees and SEBI. Each and every customer has to be informed about the change, and should give an exit option without any load, if the investor wishes to do so.
      Normally, there will be a cash reserve with each MF Scheme to handle redemption pressure and to explore any investment opportunities. Similarly, there is a regular inflow into the scheme, which they can use for handling redemption pressures if required. Existing investors will not be affected and the MF will not take any extra risk, outside their mandate.

    • pankaj bhardwaj Posted August 2, 2011 1:22 pm

      Dear Sir,

      Where can we see the sharpe ratio and alpha?kindly help me.I am new in mutual investments.

      • Finvin Posted August 2, 2011 3:02 pm

        See the site http://www.valueresearchonline.com. Go to ‘Family Scan’ and select the required Fund house. click on ‘Analyse the fund Family’ and select the particular fund. Click on ‘Performance’. But don’t make any investment decision based on these factors only. It is always better to do a goal based investment after a financial Planning.Please visit http://www.finvin.in for more details on how, you will be benefited by financial planning. All the best.

  • ABHIJIT DAS Posted June 18, 2011 12:42 pm

    Extremely helpful article for those who invests in Mutual Funds.

    CA. Abhijit Das
    9836697776

    • Finvin Posted June 18, 2011 12:48 pm

      Thanks. You can share with your friends, if you feel, it is worth.

      • Hippie Posted June 26, 2011 11:50 am

        Well done airtlce that. I’ll make sure to use it wisely.

  • CSM Rajeshkumar Posted June 23, 2011 2:48 pm

    Thanks for the Nice Article.

    My question is when a MF becomes absolete? How the investor will be informed about the closure of the MF.

    Thanks & regards,
    Rajesh

    • Finvin Posted June 23, 2011 3:46 pm

      I think, your question is when, you have to sell the fund. The ideal way is to sell it when the financial goal is approaching. You can transfer the equity mutual funds slowly to debt funds around 3 years before the target date, to guard against any market correction at that time.

  • mutul fund,mutual funds,equity mutual fund,mutual fund investments,index mutual funds,mutual fund calculato Posted December 4, 2011 7:46 pm

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am inspired! Extremely helpful info particularly the closing part 🙂 I deal with such information much. I was looking for this certain information for a very lengthy time. Thanks and best of luck.

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *